Is That a Ghost?! - Daily Controversy #11

 

Greetings, controversial readers!

Welcome to the Daily Controversy, where young writers and readers share their opinions regarding certain topics in order to see from alternative perspectives and ultimately just to have fun! I’m Joanna Mayer, one of the authors for the Controversial Book Club, and let’s dive right into this!

Today’s question is:

Is it acceptable for authors to use ghostwriters?

Now, before we move on, let’s make sure everyone is well aware of this controversial topic!

1. What is Ghostwriting?

Ghostwriting is when a writer (the ghostwriter) creates content for another person (the credited author). This often involves the ghostwriter writing a book, article, or manuscript based on the credited author's ideas or expertise. The credited author is the only one recognized as the creator of the work, and the ghostwriter's contribution is not acknowledged publicly. Ghostwriting is not limited to celebrities but also includes public figures, experts, and individuals with compelling stories but limited writing skills.

2. The Ethics of Ghostwriting

Ghostwriting has always been a topic of debate in the literary world and it raises questions about the authenticity and transparency of the work. Some people believe that using ghostwriters can harm the integrity of the author's work as readers expect a direct connection between the writer and the words on the page. However, supporters of ghostwriting highlight its practical aspects, saying that it allows individuals with interesting stories or ideas but limited writing skills to share their narratives with a wider audience. The debate is focused on who should get the primary credit - the person with the concept or the one writing the text.

3. The Role of Ghostwriters in the Industry

Ghostwriters are kind of a big deal in the publishing industry. They often team up with famous people, celebrities, or experts in different fields. Sometimes, the name of a well-known individual can generate a lot of attention from publishers and readers. However, the actual writing is often done by a skilled ghostwriter. This fact raises some questions about the value we place on a name versus the skill of the writer. It also leads to discussions about whether or not authors should openly acknowledge the help they get from ghostwriters, or if it's alright for the collaboration to remain undisclosed.

4. Balancing Artistic Expression and Commercial Success

Using ghostwriters is a bit of a double-edged sword. Some people think it's a practical way to make sure deadlines are met and books are written to market demands, while others think it could mess with an author's unique voice and style. It's all about whether the commercial success of a book should be more important than the artistic integrity of the writing process.

5. Evolving Perspectives in the Digital Age

In today's world, where people's online presence and personal branding are everything, the debate around ghostwriting is changing. Social media is making it harder to tell the difference between public figures and their audience. People are starting to care more about the personalities behind the books they read, which raises questions about honesty and transparency in the author-reader relationship. This discussion goes beyond just traditional book publishing and includes online content too. Influencers and celebrities might use ghostwriters for their blog posts, articles, and social media updates.

Now, it’s your time to shine!

With knowledge of this topic in mind, consider the question: 

Is it acceptable for authors to use ghostwriters?

Next, share your opinion in the comments, chat with other writers, and have fun. Know that you’re in an environment with teens like you who share a love for writing, reading, and fun!

Happy arguing!

— Joanna ❤

P.S. I don't like ghostwriters

P.P.S. THIS controversy WAS GHOSTWRITTEN BY JACK! HA!

Image credits: unsplash.com